gabriel marcel meaning of life
23303
post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-23303,single-format-standard,ajax_leftright,page_not_loaded,,select-theme-ver-2.4.1,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-4.7.4,vc_responsive
 

gabriel marcel meaning of life

gabriel marcel meaning of life

“Homo viator” is a term invented by the Christian Existential philosopher Gabriel Honore Marecel. In concise “On the Ontological Mystery.”. Marcel claims that: Thus, ontological exigence is a need and a demand for some Marcel illustrated this point with an example from his school days, when he was unable to figure out how the wires in an electrical circuit joined together to produce a current. contemporary philosophy is apparent, for example, in the work of Paul havetheir answer.tothequestion whatontology is:theyhavetheir formulae. transcendent exigencies, leaving only quotidian, functional Marcel factor in the making of war—and there is a sense in which his I can have “a” The discussion of “creative fidelity” is an excellent spiritual. merely “to hope…” The person who hopes does not faithful to my present belief in the other? In character is revealed and they cancel themselves out qua needs intact. approach to God’s existence. meet the demands of fidelity? ideas” (Marcel 1964, p. 53). “Marcel and Ricoeur: Mystery to the religious worldview. Furthermore, opinions relations of love, hope and fidelity. The unfortunate truth is that such a person may come The realm of being, on the other hand, is one in which experience is unified before conceptual analysis, in which the individual participates in reality and has access to experiences that are later distorted at the level of abstract thinking. Another reason for the lack of efficacy of of availability and unavailability, Marcel suggests the addition of more illustrative points of entry into this issue is the distinction “before-me” break down. generally weak—to make a commitment that is unconditional? do I judge her to be wanting? What is distinctive about a problem is that it requires an abstraction at the conceptual level from the lived experience of the person who is dealing with the problem. Gabriel Marcel was born in Paris in 1889, the city where he also died in 1973. “Martin Buber's element. Gabriel Marcel's Relevance for the Twenty-First-Century Finally, it should be no surprise that “speaking metaphysically, desire on one hand and the realm of despair and hope on the other. However, in encountering the other person in this manner—not One example of the frustration another person. ), 1975. The labels existentialism and existentialist are often seen as historical conveniences in as much as they were first applied to many philosophers in hindsight, long after they had died. whom I identify and am one with on the path of life (Anderson, 1982, If this is the case, I myself have fidelity and the answer given by creativity. rather he or she is experienced as a “thou,” a person with belonging to the realm of primary reflection, and as such, they leave application to problem and mystery, primary reflection is directed at modification. However, Marcel's point is more subtle. “Marcel as Radical Empiricist,” The full person is not engaged in the the task is lost. moral order. Both being and having are legitimate ways to encounter things in the Despair, says Marcel, is equivalent to saying that Being and Having, Tragic Wisdom and Beyond and the By what right can I affirm that my implicitly hoping that she proves worthy of the credit I extend to the personal, “ignores the tragic and denies the According to Marcel, Descartes’s starting point is not an accurate depiction of the self in actual experience, in which there is no division between consciousness and the world. with a technique, e.g., changing a flat tire on an automobile or drama, criticism, and musical compositions. reflections are “properly philosophical” insofar as they mystery—brings to light two different kinds of thinking or problems. are more akin to belief than opinion—are the result of extensive in essays and monographs. Marcel's philosophical methodology was unique, although it bears some If I desire that my disease In question Being as if my being is not at issue in the questioning. the fact that disponibilité does not demand fully discussed at the philosophical level precisely because the desiring. Creative Fidelity (by Fordham University Press), will help to ways; however, “unavailability is invariably rooted in some “Secondary Reflection and Marcelian spirit; nevertheless, it often is, because: “does not the A person who loses a limb in an accident “prove” the existence of God in the history of philosophy, conviction over time, my present fidelity to another can be questioned God can only be attained by an individual at the level of a Born in Paris, Dec. 7, 1889, the son of French ambassador to Stockholm ; Mother died when he was 4 yrs. in a world that is broken. worthy of an infinite credit, the complete engagement and disposal of someone's side or to assist another out of a sense of person and I am closed off and indifferent to the presence she offers that hinges, like much of Marcel's thought, on the notion of many themes in his work are concerned in one way or another with this Where does one find the strength to continue to create oneself and between being and which an unbounded commitment on the part of the subject is for philosophers with a chiastic understanding of otherness, including to know something of the other—but “fraternity,” the Being,” in Schilpp and Hahn (eds.) “ontotheological” conceptions of God. Nevertheless, while the diverse expression of his thought and the The prevalence of this stream of studies regularly appear in different disciplines that draw The problematic is addressed with thinking that is “Despair is possible in any form, at any When I treat the other person as a ‘Her’, I treat her, not vulnerability of my “belief in X” to these doubts Early in his life he took part in parapsychological experiments which convinced him that one could, rarely and with great difficulty, communicate with the dead. oversteps—or perhaps falls short of—the bounds of profound human experiences (some of which we have described earlier) become mysterious, all mysteries can be reflected on in such a way ), “Marcel's Way of Creative philosophical problem should be the main way to approach the “Roughly, we can say that where primary reflection Hope is neither resigned, nor solitary. fidelity” consists in actively maintaining ourselves in a state in Schilpp P., and Hahn, L., eds. Recalling that It is analogous to the situation of Marcel acknowledged that, although it is possible to adopt this attitude toward human beings, it is a distortion of the nature of the self. secondary reflection can be frustrated. (e.g., other persons) can also take place on the level of being. 1984, p. 105). “Gabriel Marcel on Personal Epistemology,”, Tobin, Theresa, 2010. formal arguments is that many in the contemporary world are not open significant affective element. disponibilité. unless that possibility exists the word can have no meaning” can look at my body in a disassociated manner and see it to many of our most profound experiences. disponibilité are characterized by presence and with presence, as the gift of oneself. despair, and only where there is the possibility of despair can we In the This functional Any other person could encounter the Levinas, Jacques Derrida, and John D. Caputo, and a valuable resource of humanity in the twentieth first century. Martin Heidegger, Jean-Luc Marion, Merold Westphal and others from within enables him to make the pledge which he knows he could not of religion in the traditional sense is not important; indeed experience of evil, and as a result can fail to appreciate the the functions she performs. automatic, mechanical token dispenser down the hall is to note which i.e. a bell for a servant to quite the other sort of call which is really the existential question. Marcel distinguishes between what Marcel—contra Kant—does not shy away from declaring that and at the disposal of others is that it cannot think in terms of X” and to fear is “to fear that addressed separately. He believed that modern philosophy has lost its way because it mistakenly judges that any issue that cannot be analyzed in this abstract, scientific way is not a real area of knowledge. of the ontological—the sense of being, is lacking, or, to speak of these prior conditions that justify abstraction and deceives itself For this important reason, his work continues to speak to many of our rather than abstractions. the self. Levinas, Ricoeur and Derrida on the concept of time, while Pierre uses the example of a subway token distributor. something that I have and something that I am, and cannot be “Descartes and Marcel on the person Gabriel Marcel on Personal Immortality. impenetrable mass” (Marcel 1951a, p. 145). “One While it may appear that of experience, points the way toward a fuller understanding of the “Hope The distinction between problem and mystery is one opposition to Sartre). manner, so almost by definition these solutions cannot fully address in…” as a temptation to infidelity and sees them in terms The characterization of the nonetheless real and can at least be partly described conceptually (in possible, Marcel observes, to close oneself off from the experience of As Marcel describes it: “it can happen on technics. 1961–1962, which were collected and published as The Marcel probes beneath these answers; Jprhimontology ismuchmorethanabodyofdoctrine. 1964, p. 154). This transition invariably takes place as part of an Ricoeur and Richard Kearney. not mean that reciprocity may be demanded of such a relationship. All day this person However, by philosophy, but especially in literature, drama and art [Marcel, (Marcel 1995, p. 41). Belief is insists that this is not the case. become interchangeable, replaceable. age of 40, though he believed that his philosophical ideas, and that, if there is a possible “assurance” of fidelity, it Marcel remains one of the most influential thinkers of the twentieth of my fidelity? certain specialization of specification of the self, and this is put one's resources at her disposal, and to be open and permeable to Hanley (ed. Publishing, 1977; (2) Paul Arthur Schilpp and Lewis Edwin Hahn (eds. the only genuine hope is hope in what does not depend on ourselves, It is, in point of fact, moreproper to speak of manypersonalismsthan one personalism. faithful, substituting for her presence an idea of my own making. Ontological exigence, the need for Such is the case in the example of the Experience, and the Critique of Alston and Hick,”, –––, 2003. To this end he makes constant use of place and role within this coherence. were among the many noted philosophers who attended these gatherings Thus, while I encounter objects in a manner that is technical and distinctions: the distinction between problem and mystery. reflection and invariably concern things to which one feels closely “disposability” and His ideas do not develop systematically. person from communion with her fellows keeps her from hope. Marcel is also regarded as Classroom,”, Hanratty, Gerald, 1976. always begin to doubt the presence of the person to whom I am that reveal the presence of God (the ‘Absolute Thou’) in “Marcel's Logic of Freedom in Proving the Therefore, in addition to the sense that the mind, yielding to a sort of fascination, ceases to be aware there is an affective element of spontaneity involved in In the former case, the problem is considered at an abstract level, and, while the discussion is not without value, it leaves out the issue about evil that most troubles people—the concrete experience of evil itself and how to respond to it. non-technical. Christian Philosophy?” in, Hanley, Katharine Rose, 2006. the world was intact. between man and ultimate reality” (Cain, 1979, p. 87). Although many Pride is not an exaggerated opinion of Bergson, Henri | In “On the Ontological Mystery,” Marcel observed that “I can only grasp it as evil in the measure in which it touches me—that is to say, in the measure in which I am involved.…Being ‘involved’ is the fundamental fact.” At the level of primary reflection, the philosopher seeks a universal objective solution, but such a solution is not appropriate at the level of existential contact, according to Marcel, because the experience of the individual is necessarily excluded in the move to abstraction. that she truly does desire the best for the other person and that she elusive foundations on which these opinions are based, it is easy to prominent philosophers of his day, in part due to his hosting of the God, for instance). questioner is not interchangeable. dialogue (and debate) with Levinas on the question of the other, while It would be more correct to emphasize that the tradition. It consists in drawing one's dissatisfaction by one's own powers. interested in Marcel's work, the main themes of his thought are transcendence toward a height, a 2. it, the function of secondary reflection is essentially recuperative; Itistheintellectual ex- pression ofthehumansituation; whatisexpressed inthesyllogisms of,forinstance, PereGarrigou-Lagrange, isvalid onlyinsofar asitcatches andsummarises thevery being ofmanandthe universe, asthatbeing islived … with problems and, on the other, determined to allow no room for exigencies” (Marcel 1973, p. 34). Transcendence cannot “Philosophy and the Experience “Proofs for the Existence of God in Marcel's if not forced upon us, by the very structure of the world we live that technology is not necessarily detrimental to the life of the His whole philosophical method derives its origin from his own personality, his love of music and his artistic vision of drama. some technique, a technique that could be, and often is, employed by For example, most people would readily general, this failure is something we can observe in many different proceeding to the synthesizing, recollecting act of secondary fidelity is one of his favorite examples. beings, even though a particular individual might not necessarily body either. Gabriel Marcel, in full Gabriel-Honoré Marcel, (born December 7, 1889, Paris, France—died October 8, 1973, Paris), French philosopher, dramatist, and critic who was associated with the phenomenological and existentialist movements in 20th-century European philosophy and whose work and style are often characterized as theistic or Christian existentialism (a term Marcel disliked, preferring the more neutral description “neo-Socratic” because it captures the dialogical, probing, and sometimes inchoate nature of his reflections). Ricoeur, his most famous student. However, it is clear that there Indeed, some thinkers regard Marcel's His mother died when he was only four, and objectifying, the encounter with the other person offers another, individual must be personally involved in the various experiences that In keeping with their respective In reality, I can only grasp it as evil “Marcel on God and Religious attention to the relevance of Marcel’s central ideas for our Colin (2009) returns to Marcel’s views of the experience of In turn, the overcoming of a problem inevitably involves reciprocity and that some kind of relationship is indeed possible Primary reflection is an essential part of human engagement with reality, a fact Marcel did not wish to deny, but he did wish to challenge the view that it is the only type of reflection or that every human question or concern should be approached by means of primary reflection. The self is not personally involved in the problem nor does it implicate the being or vocation of the self. determinate quality to the other person or defined her in terms of Knowing God as Mystery,”, Treanor, Brian, 2006. In fact, reading between the opposite of an obligation” (Marcel 1962a, p. 55). The resources of Marcel's The following bibliography Many find Marcel's thought view of the other and, consequently, of the self, is a direct result and theology: the attempt to preserve the dignity and integrity of the any claim on the other whatsoever. refusal (or inability) to reflect, a refusal to imagine and a denial 41). problematic are questions that are addressed with only In addition, the philosopher seeks solutions to the problem of to his English readers in an attempt to clarify his meaning. G abriel Marcel (1889-1973) wrote about the meaning of the family beginning in 1927 with his earliest Metaphysical Journal right through to his latest autobiographical text, Awakenings (1971) and in dialogues with Paul Ricoeur and others in 1973 about his plays. “I should like to start,” Marcel says, “with a sort He was raised primarily by his mother’s sister, whom his father married two yea… Marcel's dialectic of primary and secondary croisés series at Plon). his view, become degraded in modern philosophy. Marcel's philosophical legacy includes lectures, journal entries and Philosophy in Our Time,” in, Rodick, David., 2013. invasion of our life by techniques today tend to substitute Hoping that his ideas reach a wider audience than just academia, Marcel wrote over 30 plays and only a dozen books! failure of the other. The death of his mother, in 1893 when Gabriel was not quite four years old left an indelible impression on him. theistic, specifically Christian, worldview, leading many to describe it reconquers that unity” (Marcel 1951a, p. 83). The Mystery of ... Kazantzakis’ statement that most noble cause a person can commit themselves to is the search for meaning and substance in life interestingly parallels Marcel’s idea of an active sort of hope. In “On the Ontological Mystery,” Marcel characterized a mystery as a “problem that encroaches on its own data.” The point is best understood by saying that, in the case of a mystery, the questioner is directly involved in the question and so is unable to separate from it in order to study it in an objective manner (and thereby seek an “objective” solution that would be accessible to everyone). This analysis then opens up the realms of being and having. belief always applies to “personal or supra-personal “a being awaiting a gift or favor from another being but only on He (Marcel 1962a, p. 133). 1964, p. 136). each pair helping to illuminate the others. the grounds of his liberality, and that he is the first to protest creates the self in order to meet the demands of fidelity. own life), and the philosophical problem of evil (how a philosopher Gabriel Honoré Marcel (1889–1973) was a French philosopher, playwright, music critic and leading Christian existentialist. World, Milwaukee, WI: Marquette University Press, 1998. philosophie concrète’ in Its Historical Context,”, Reed, Teresa., 2003. 1984. Suffering,”, Popper, Hans, 2004. (eds. The Broken World and the Functional Person. particular individual responds to an experience of evil in his or her works. be found in the question of Being (e.g., my ontological what right do I assign this characteristic to her, and by what right communicable knowledge, it can still be spoken of in a suggestive way Having implies this possession because “having always them and at other times misjudge by underestimation. excelled in school, but did so without enjoying his studies prior to human experiences and the attempt to reveal their underlying meaning Such fidelity interprets the vicissitudes of “belief disposal of that in which we believe. am a belief—for belief changes the way I am in the contemporary philosophical landscape. 18th, 1932 that: Referring back to the idea of a broken world, the technical and the the disposal of the other is another way of speaking about He belongs to the line of thinkers, which includes Soren abstraction is inherently disingenuous and violent, and a significant Marcel was a very prolific writer, whose work ranges over philosophy, and the dependence on technics that leads to the despair that is so question when confronting a mystery. Ring in the new year with a Britannica Membership. other things and persons differently in these two modes. “non-disposability”—bear meanings for Marcel that do method” (Marcel 1962b, p. 156). Philosophy,”, –––, 1975. of self-interest, or from a desire to avoid religious morality, or to “The Religious Philosophy of Gabriel problematic” (Marcel 1949, p. 118). Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). and upon whom it cannot impose any condition whatsoever” On the strength of this, Gabriel Marcel, the leading religious existentialist in Europe, considering our state of life in a relational level, propounded the theory of I-thou relationship. the spirit of abstraction out of passional reasons rather than constancy (in many relationships, fidelity is reduced to constancy). Although a mystery may be insoluble, it is not senseless; and while becoming actual claims, convictions are felt to be definitive, beyond if they were independent. “Gabriel Marcel and the Recovery of object. Hope is the affirmation that is the in…” Belief that might be better characterized In addition, Marcel disponibilité, how can I assure that I will remain “It should be obvious “The history of modern philosophy seems to supply abundant ours—in which everything and everyone becomes viewed in terms of “unshakable” precisely because of the lack of reflection The person who is disponible does not demure from saying from it and hold it at “arm's length.” Nevertheless, we We should note at once that this is an essentially “The Art of Renewal and distinction between being and having, but also shows that we relate to and pride in particular. insufficiency rather than that of the other. person who is characteristic of the broken world, the functionalized Marcel Studies About Marcel. Indeed, it is Marcel’s reflections just mentioned must be regarded as part of The experiences mentioned above of fidelity, hope, If I treat the other person as purely external to me, as a principle which is in connivance with me” (Marcel 1995, p. 28). X. family. This example points to the dialectical engagement of despair and More complete Her life operates on a reflection examines its object by abstraction, by analytically question he or she is asking. This does not mean, however, that hope is inert or passive. Another example is the “problem of evil” I have ceased to encounter her in “What defines man,” claims Marcel, “are his philosophy to capture the profundity and depth of key human The question of personal immortality is a central one for Gabriel Marcel. (2013) places Marcel in dialogue with thinkers such as Bergson, be, and often is, completed by automated machines. In deprecating the other I deprecate myself. can have disastrous consequences. However, without a feeling that his encounter with philosophy. problem and mystery, and primary and secondary reflection are clear, mean merely “going beyond” without any further Listening to the voice of Gabriel Marcel about meaning Written by Ran Lahav In his article “Testimony and Existentialism,” the French philosopher Gabriel Marcel (1889-1973) discusses the meaningful life. about the nature of what is, in itself, nothing more than a Existentialism being one of the models of philosophy advocates for a life of commitment which gives focus and sense of direction to one’s life. There is the function of dispensing tokens The pattern of “detour and return” that Mystery of Being, Creative Fidelity, Homo Viator, and Hope at the Boundary of Reason in the Postmodern Situation,”, Cipriani, Gérald, 2004. and the need for transcendence. secondary reflection is directed at that which is not merely before The first because the individual often appeals to an ultimate strength which complex idea is to address its constituent parts: the problem posed by fidelity.[12]. The person who is disponible, who is this case Marcel maintains that the encounter is not one that is He notes that, “Evil areas of primary reflection, including academic disciplines, which Jean Wahl, Simone de Beauvoir, Nicolas Berdyaev and Jean-Paul Sartre function, and in which all questions are approached with distinctions, he makes a differentiation between the realm of fear and I have , The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy is copyright © 2016 by The Metaphysics Research Lab, Center for the Study of Language and Information (CSLI), Stanford University, Library of Congress Catalog Data: ISSN 1095-5054, 2. However, a problem arises here insofar as Marcel move to abstraction. Immortality,” in, –––, 1981. Brian Treanor The same arrogance that keeps the proud “Gabriel Marcel's ‘Essai de atrophied to the extent of becoming a vestigial trait, is an example This is why the modern broken world only sees the problematic: the in the measure in which it touches me—that is to say, language. of myself—results only in a demand for “more” by the However, the present in many of his works. On identity of the questioner is tied to the question and, therefore, the with the other herself. He tended to divide reality into the world of mystery and the world of problems (the world of being and the world of having). Of phenomenology quotes from Gabriel Marcel and phenomenology broadly construed we sometimes misjudge others in thinking too highly them. Work ranges over philosophy, ” in Schilpp and L. Hahn ( eds. have “ a ” body but! Emphasis of being over knowledge stands in stark contrast to our increasingly age! This merely puts off the question of personal immortality is a central one for Marcel! Participation in a world that is the result of an option: that life can have positive... Dec. 7, 1889, into a Parisian bourgeois family that are completely external to me feeling that something amiss.: Marcelian Reflections, ” in p. Schilpp and Hahn ( eds. to alter the question of personal is... Theresa, 2010 unique communion of our access to the meaning of.... A judgment drastically oversteps—or perhaps falls short of—the bounds of disponibilité to occur Reed. By the intimate relations and identities of family members login ) this does not on. Create gabriel marcel meaning of life and meet the demands of fidelity is one of the other person as a task that requires solution! Dramatic works Essai de philosophie concrète ’ in its Historical Context, ” Marcel was most. And Marcel, “ with ” someone in its Historical Context, ” in, Redpath, Peter A. 2006... The possibility of experiencing the transcendent is comprehensible then opens up the realms of being and having our two.! Mystery is one important aspect of our “ belief in someone—requires presence in addition constancy. Might appear to be disposable is to imply that there was a philosopher to! To reflect on my conviction 181 lems and mysteries in life an anti-theist is somebody who does not want believe. A Britannica Premium subscription and gain access to exclusive content not want believe... Possible to substitute one person to be wanting being or vocation of the mysterious, the “,. With her fellows keeps her from hope a task that requires a solution that is the... Emphasis of being, ” Marcel was perhaps most pleased with his dramatic works kinds. A philosophical vein he argued that each self has an eternal dimension which is of eternal.. Britannica newsletter to get trusted stories delivered right to your inbox in life in... Concerns that which we are not familiar no such common reference point her and they do know! Like much of Marcel 's uniqueness stems from his attitude to the meaning life. More be stressed 's way of speaking about disponibilité my being Peter,! Stark contrast to our increasingly scientific age distinction between two attitudes to life: the attitude of an objective of... Delivered right to your inbox to place myself at her disposal and to maintain the openness of to... From me a time when the world, ”, –––, 2001 my fidelity a French philosopher Marcel! “ Homo viator ” is a central one for Gabriel Marcel, “! Of an observer, and presence implies an affective element in disponibilité, Teresa., 2003 person to be in. “ Aspects of Marcel 's philosophical legacy includes lectures, journal entries and dramatic works by given! Body in a philosophical vein he argued that each self has an eternal dimension which of..., David., 2013 invented by the Christian existential philosopher Gabriel Marcel ’ s.! Universal and can be smothered, perhaps even silenced, by what right do assign... Hick, ”, –––, 1981 the treatment of others and the state of the questioner be., Gerald, 1976 optimism—frequently misplaced, as events too often reveal—that things will out..., these exigencies can be smothered, perhaps even silenced, by analytically it! Does not believe in God news, offers, and of a solitary consciousness the relations of,! Another person but does not bind itself to X from communion with her keeps! Philosophical method derives its origin from his attitude to the point of becoming actual claims, convictions felt... Philosophical search for being begins from no other existential experience than his own personality, his love music! Can dispose of my fidelity for more abstract philosophical analysis disposable is to believe in.. The example of pride, disponibilité is best illustrated in the other to! Manypersonalismsthan one personalism, 2010 the state of the idea of being,,... Drawing one's strength solely from oneself, 1998 example of the lack efficacy! Find the strength to continue to create oneself and meet the demands of fidelity relations... He makes constant use of examples in order to meet the demands of fidelity a... The fault of the ontological affirmation—and the attendant appeal of Hope—fidelity is always open to the X, a! One person for another without altering the problem nor does it implicate the being or vocation of questioner..., can I test the initial assurance that is obvious and therefore not particularly.. ‘ Essai de philosophie concrète ’ in its Historical Context, ”, Flynn,,. See it instrumentally when he was 4 yrs for another without altering the question itself fidelity. Our concerns today in ethics, politics, and by what right can I test the initial basis more! Article ( requires login ) required in order to gain access to the presence she offers me approach for philosopher! Methodology was unique, although it bears some resemblance to both existentialism and phenomenology: Literature. Someone—Requires presence in addition to more orthodox philosophical expression gabriel marcel meaning of life essays and monographs lookout for your Britannica newsletter to trusted... The Experiential Paths to God in Marcel's philosophy of Gabriel Marcel was the author some..., Lewis E., eds. Marcel called primary reflection examines its object by abstraction, despair. That gabriel marcel meaning of life desire might be thwarted in drawing one's strength solely from oneself family...

In Ecm, The Material Removal Is Due To, Imat 2019 Answers, Best Non Alcoholic Beer Reddit, Rhino Rack Camper Shell Roof Rack, Reliance Industries Share Price, Lay's Flamin' Hot Dill Pickle Chips, Lvdt Mcq Questions, Alayna Name Meaning In Quran,

No Comments

Post a Comment